18 Celebrating 18 years of scratch-made sweets · Baking since 2008
Bonnye Randolph · ServSafe Certified · Owner & Baker Call or text: (609) 954-0399
BJ's Sweets ~n~ EatsScratch-made · New Jersey

The menu

Cakes & Pies

Every cake and pie is baked to order. Every cake and pie is baked to order. Prices are a starting point, custom flavors, sizes, and decoration are always welcome, just ask.

Cupcakes

Sold by the dozen
  • Banana Pudding NEW$25
  • Lemon NEW$20
  • Peppermint Bark NEW$25
  • Pumpkin NEW$20
  • Almond Joy$25
  • Carrot$20
  • Chocolate$20
  • Hummingbird$20
  • Key Lime$20
  • Red Velvet$20
  • Yellow$20

Layer Cakes & Pound Cakes

Whole cakes
  • Oreo Cookie Chocolate Pound NEW$45
  • Oreo Cookie Lemon NEW$45
  • Jamaican Black$50
  • Rum Cake$30
  • Red Velvet$35
  • Carrot (3 Layers)$30
  • Coconut Pineapple (3 Layers)$30
  • German Chocolate$30
  • Praline Pound w/ Bourbon Glaze$30
  • Sour Cream Pound$30
  • Lemon Pound$30
  • Almond Pound$30
  • Black Walnut Pound$30
  • Butterscotch Pound$30
  • Red Velvet Pound$30
  • 7-Up$30
  • Strawberry$30
  • Cookies and Cream$30
  • Chocolate Orange Passion$30
  • Oreo Cookie Pound$40
  • Pineapple Upside Down w/ Pecans$25
  • Caramel Apple Walnut$20
  • Hummingbird$20

Pies

9-inch, baked to order
  • Sweet Potato$15
  • Bourbon Pecan$15
  • Banana Pudding Pie$30
  • Coconut Custard$15
  • Lemon Meringue$15
  • Apple$15
  • Cheddar Cheese Apple$20
  • Cherry$15
  • Blueberry$15
  • Mango$15
  • Praline Pumpkin$15
  • Apple Butter Pumpkin$15
  • Strawberry Rhubarb$20
  • Very Berry Apple$20
  • Bean$12
  • Squash$15

Sheet Cakes & Party Sizes

Feeds a crowd
  • Sheet Cake w/ filling$45
  • Sheet Cake w/o filling$40
  • ½ Sheet Cake w/ filling$30
  • ½ Sheet Cake w/o filling$25
  • Punch Bowl (Large)$50
  • Punch Bowl (Small)$25
  • Mini Pie "Personal Size" (Sweet Potato / Bean)$6
  • Mini Banana Pudding "Personal"$6

Ready to order?

Tell us what you'd like and when you need it, and we'll take care of the rest.

Place an order